Nov 19 2010
i like television
Earlier today someone on Reddit started a poll to find out “What’s your favorite television show across time and genres?” That’s a pretty broad brush for a survey. I have a hard time picking my favorite ice cream, much less my favorite work in a certain medium.
Part of the problem I think is that shows on this side of the pond are expected to run for too long. It’s hard to maintain perfection over a lengthy period of time, not to mention adequate character development. Look at Fawlty Towers — two seasons of six episodes, and they’re almost all perfect. Compare that to the Simpsons, which has been on television for 22 seasons: some seasons have been magnificent while others were utter crap. The overall impression is pretty mixed, though, which personally would knock it off my list of favorite shows of all time despite points of brilliance.
The only show I can think of that doesn’t stick to the “longer run = worse show” formula is Seinfeld. Seinfeld was on the air for nine seasons, but was saved in part by the fact that the characters really never developed and the plots were about nothing. The episodes were pretty self-contained with few callbacks to previous events, and “Jerry is a jerk and steals a marble rye” was fairly interchangeable with “Jerry is a jerk and makes out during Schindler’s List”. (As with all the best shows, having exceedingly good writers helps.)
So I guess being canceled early or being British are your best bets for television greatness.
Okay, links:
* The TV Tropes page for Community’s amazing Modern Warfare episode. But didn’t I link to a Community-related thing just yesterday? It’s almost like I’ve become a huge Community fangirl and am trying to convince people to watch it on Thursday nights on NBC (or the internet)!
* What’s Alan Watching covers The Wire for newbies. I just started this series last night, and I can already tell that it’s going to be amazing. I adore Oz** and loved Homicide: Life on the Street, and both of those shows supplied much of the on- and off-screen talent. It’s really big and confusing and interwoven, though, so a viewer’s guide like this can be handy.
* The 8 Best Running Jokes in Arrested Development. If you are one of my friends who does not watch Arrested Development: a) god, just watch the damn show already; and b) viewing these videos might explain a number of my verbal idiosyncracies. (Me: “Steve Holt!” Friend: “What?” Me: “Steve Holt?” Friend: “No, you’re Jessica.” Me: *exasperated sigh*)
* Also, a random news article unrelated to television: Police alerted to superheroes patrolling Seattle. I liked the description of one of them driving around in his godmother’s Kia, doing good deeds.
** Well hell, as I was writing that I realized that Oz also bucks the shorter is better rule. Harumph. It also would be one of my favorite shows ever.

